Mr. Popular. Definitely not Mr. Typical.
America’s favorite kind of cookie, but done in a way only Otterbein’s can. With real semi-sweet chocolate, butter, brown sugar, and a few other simple ingredients.
Enjoy Otterbein’s Cookies known for our red and white checkered bag. These delicious, thin and crispy cookies hold approx. 7oz of cookies. Perfect for any occasion.
*All cookies are accounted by weight.
Please note that due to longer than expected shipping times any orders placed should be expected to arrive in 2021. Dismiss
Join Our Mailing List
Receive a 10% off coupon code to be used on your first order.