Shop

Mr. Popular. Definitely not Mr. Typical.
America’s favorite kind of cookie, but done in a way only Otterbein’s can. With real semi-sweet chocolate, butter, brown sugar, and a few other simple ingredients.

Enjoy Otterbein’s Cookies known for our red and white checkered bag. These delicious, thin and crispy cookies hold approx. 7oz of cookies. Perfect for any occasion.

*All cookies are accounted by weight.