Our Cookies

Otterbein’s has been making cookies since 1881. We’ve added a few new flavors since then, but we keep things simple. We use just a few high-quality ingredients in each cookie: no fillers, no artificial flavors, no preservatives. They’re made with natural ingredients and stay fresh for weeks—but once you taste them, they won’t last long. ORDER YOUR FAVORITES OR TRY ALL SIX—available in attractive gift tins. We ship anywhere!