Imperfect Perfection.

Ever notice how almost all store-bought cookies look alike? Even the bumps and imperfections seem a little too perfect. Not Otterbein’s. Every one of our cookies is unique. They have personality. They have soul. There’s nothing better because there’s nothing cookie cutter about ‘em.

Order Now

Cookie Snap

Don’t End Up With
An Empty Bag!

Sign up for our newsletter and don’t miss a crumb of information.

Oatmeal Cookie
Image of Cookies Overhead

Since 1881. Fresher Than Ever.

Not much has changed since our family started baking these beauties in a little row home in Baltimore. And you know what they say, the more things stay the same, the more they get devoured. Or something like that.

Learn More