Skip to content

Sugar Cookies

Thin. Crispy. Perfect?

Loading image:

The Cookie That Started it All

How can something so simple be so simply delicious? Fortunately, we don’t have to explain, we just have to prove it. And we do. Like we have since 1881. Just six ingredients playing sweetly together.

Shop Now
Loading image:

Thin, Crispy, and Steeped in Tradition.

Since 1881, our Sugar Cookies have been made in the same unmistakable style — paper-thin, golden, and delightfully crisp. While we no longer roll each batch by hand like our great-grandparents did, we’ve preserved every bit of the craft and care that made them a family favorite for over a century. One bite, and you’ll taste 144 years of tradition in that signature, delicate crunch.

Shop Now

Ingredeints

wheat flour, sugar, margarine, eggs, salt, ammonium carbonate.

Cookie Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Cookie Count

Each 7oz bag of Otterbein's Sugar Cookies contains approximately 22 cookies.

Magasinsu Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com Magasins U

Kosher

All Otterbein's Cookies are Kosher in accordance with The Union of Orthodox Jewish Congregations of America.

Smile Streamline Icon: https://streamlinehq.com

Smile Guarantee

If our cookies don't put a smile on your face, we will happily refund you.

Back to top