Baked in Maryland since 1881

Sugar Cookies

$41.99 $10.50 / bag · 7 oz bags

Simple never tasted so good.

Choose your boxMore bags, lower price per bag
Free shipping, every order
Delivered in 3–7 business days
Real, simple ingredients
  • Light, crispy & perfectly sweet
  • Made with simple, real ingredients
  • Made in USA for 145 years
  • Great for sharing, gifting, or keeping stocked

Thin. Crisp. Timeless.

Six simple ingredients. One unmistakable cookie.

Since 1881, Otterbein’s Sugar Cookies have been baked in the same signature style — paper-thin, delicately crisp, and impossible to stop eating.

Still made with the same classic recipe that made them a Maryland favorite over a century ago.

  • Thin & crispy texture
  • Made with just 6 ingredients
  • Baked fresh in Maryland
  • Approx. 22 cookies per bag

1881

Baked by the same Maryland family for five generations.

Thin

Rolled impossibly thin for a light, shattering crunch.

Real

Real butter, real chocolate, simple ingredients.

A Maryland family tradition

Same family. Same recipe. Since 1881.

Otterbein's started as a local Maryland bakery with one simple idea: make a memorable thin-and-crispy cookie and keep sharing it with generations of families. More than 140 years later, that signature crunch remains at the heart of every bag.

Read our story

What cookie fans are saying

★★★★★

I brought Otterbein’s cookies to a school event and had parents asking where they could buy them before the event was even over.

Rachel H., School Counselor
★★★★★

I stocked our office snack area with Otterbein’s and they were the first thing to disappear. Now the team expects them at every meeting.

James K., Operations Manager
★★★★★

The Ginger Cookies are in a category of their own—thin, crisp, and full of flavor. Once you try them, every other cookie feels too heavy.

Melissa T., Food Blogger

Free Shipping on All Orders

Order your favorite flavors, variety packs, or larger assortments and have them delivered directly to your door.

Questions, answered